Also write about the accuracy, validity, and relevance of the results of the article review. It is not in your interest for me to have to guess what you're writing about. The sample excludes students who dropped out or graduated during the survey period. Hence, in an attempt to tackle the problems prevalent in academic writing, this study set out to investigate the effect of. You need to give the reader an idea of whether the author of an article based it on facts and credible information. Materials and Methods Similar to a recipe, the description of materials and methods will allow others to replicate the study elsewhere if needed.
Using descriptive research methodologies with the educational setting may be advantageous for several reasons. Do not repeat text verbatim or give references in this section. This article did an exceptional job of providing detailed data and graphs to support the authors claims. With regard to coaching level, 25 0. If you want to learn how to critique an article, you should first have a clear understanding of what this assignment is about. The graph shows the increase in savings over time.
If it is a scientific review article, it uses database searches to portray the research. Limitations of the research are often included here. You have the burden of proof to demonstrate that you know what you are doing. Describe the work in your own words. Think about the central purpose or argument of the article usually found in the introduction.
Its purpose is to evaluate the ideas or arguments presented in the article. It is your way of making the whole process of creating an article critique simple and fun, following all the common rules and regulations. Julia Klaus has been a writer and copy editor for three years. A journal article reporting original research including data and findings, e. Many believe that our nations social policy on drugs have been the cause of the growth of gangs, in other words the growth of the drug trades.
Publication bias can occur when editors only accept manuscripts that have a bearing on the direction of their own research, or reject manuscripts with negative findings. Despite findings from previous research, there was a lack of knowledge regarding if. If there are both simple and complicated variables in your article and you choose to talk about the simple ones, I will assume you do not understand operationalization, which is not in your best interests. Your review must be on an article reporting structured research, that is, one with variables, statistical analyses, relationships among variables, etc. During these years, the same students were surveyed to see how their circumstances had changed between eighth and twelfth grades.
Any description of a means of calculation of a specific result is always a description of a method and never a description of a methodology. If there are only a few relevant findings, list all of them, but if there are many, list only the few that you think are most important. Year, Month Date of Publication. There were significant differences between the three levels. When you know the answers to these questions, you may start writing your. Your answer to this should be based on what the author says in the introduction to the article, not in the methods section.
The nature of the sport could also be critical. The interviews were collected from many different youth from different ages, they also interviewed different ethnic groups and both male and females. Descriptive research can involve collecting quantitative information, or it can describe categories of information such as patterns of interaction when using technology in the classroom. Often articles that use one of the well-known large national probability samples do not give much information about the sample because they assume that professionals will recognize the sample title and already know the basic information. Balance the positive and negative. Critique the Article Present the strengths and weaknesses that you have found in the article.
Do the relationships observed above only deal with gang members or non-gang members? Another tip that I have for you is to remember that a literature review still needs a thesis statement. Past issues are bound in hardcover by volume and kept on the first and second floors of the south stacks of Memorial Library. A research paper is a. I simply cannot grade your review without the photocopy. Generally, it is an objective analysis of any piece of work not depending on its genre , which includes your personal thoughts on the subject. That is, choose the variable that must have been hardest for the author s to figure out how to measure, or how to make the conceptual-operational link.
Following the information on threats to internal validity, the student provided suggestions regarding how these threats could have been dealt with. Give way forward for future research in the field of study. Descriptive research plays an important role in educational research because it has greatly increased our knowledge about what happens in the classroom. Often a particular hypothesis is supported by several different findings which show that the bivariate relation holds true after other variables have been statistically controlled, or when the research design is altered, or when the variables are measured in different ways. An Article Review is a critical, constructive evaluation of literature in a particular field through summary, classification, analysis, and comparison. Junior high coaches were significantly lower in training and instruction than either high school or college coaches. Give 1 relevant background 2 explain why the work was done 3 summarize results and explain the method.
In some studies there are two or more sources of data. Thousand Oaks, California: Sage Publications. High school coaches scored much higher than college level coaches in democratic behavior. A working rule is: if you can't understand the statistical analyses presented in the results section, don't choose the article. Questions were asked regarding their involvement with gangs, drugs and violence, these are all important factors to determine the outcome of the study. This was the only critical measure used in this study. Your thesis should be a brief statement that summarizes your overall evaluation of the work being critiqued.